Preview Mode Links will not work in preview mode

The Catholic Culture Podcast

A weekly podcast hosted by musician and writer Thomas V. Mirus, exploring everything Catholic, with a special focus on arts and culture. Dedicated to the Holy Family. An extension of

Jan 19, 2020

We've all heard the complaints about Catholic dating. Catholics have trouble with the concept of "casual dating" because they (rightly) see dating as oriented toward marriage but (wrongly) put all that weight on a single date. Some are perpetually "discerning" without ever really going anywhere. Women feel like if they don't find a spouse during their four years at a Catholic college, they've missed their chance.

Some problems we share with the rest of the world: Men won't ask women out because they're timid or tranquilized by video games and porn. Women often feel they have to put on a persona, whether of a Jane Austen character or a "fierce" feminist (YAAAAS, SLAY QUEEN!).

Matchmaker Emily Zanotti, known as the "Catholic Yenta", joins the show to discuss these and other pathologies of Catholic dating, and explains how she went from helping her friends find their spouses to handpicking matches for people across the country.

Also interviewed is Eric Niehaus, creator of a soon-to-be-launched events app called Koin, which will allow Catholics to find and plan activities and events with other Catholics in their area. In a world in which Catholics often feel socially isolated, Koin aims to help us foster real-life community.

Pt. 1: Emily Zanotti (Catholic Yenta)

[2:55] How Emily found herself in the role of Catholic matchmaker

[5:32] Why a matchmaker is in demand; problems with dating sites

[6:47] How the matchmaking process works and Emily’s role in follow-up

[9:31] What information is useful to Emily in matching people; prayer as the basis of the process

[12:23] Success rate so far, future expansion

[15:03] What Emily has learned talking to Jewish and Hindu matchmakers

[18:39] Common issues and complaints from the Catholic dating scene

[23:34] “Perpetual discernment” and unrealistic expectations in the Catholic dating pool

[28:35] Risk, security and the Disney princess syndrome

[30:29] Male timidity and sloth exacerbated by video games, porn, and feminism

[34:58] Why some women think they need to put on a persona when dating

Pt. 2: Eric Niehaus (Koin)

[42:20] The meaning of the name Koin and the need for a specifically Catholic events app

[44:45] Planned growth of the platform, city by city

[46:36] Challenges of getting a new social platform off the ground

[48:47] Cultivating community both in pre-existing organizations and parishes and in the wider geographical area

[50:51] How Koin aims to partner with and compliment parishes

[54:06] Extending participation beyond the young adult bracket; the benefits of spending time with people who aren't your age

[57:52] Overcoming social stratification among Catholics


Catholic Yenta form

Emily Zanotti on Twitter


This podcast is a production of If you like the show, please consider supporting us!